Stop trying to rationalize everything, will ya? Let's face it, we have a mystery on our hands!

Sure you have. A real one! Whose body was it and where is it now? A completely normal mystery. Whatever it is, it's well within the bounds of human experience and I don't think you ought to make any more of it.

Look, I wouldn't if I hadn't looked in Becky's cellar! How do you explain away the body I saw there?

I don't think you saw one there.

You don't think I saw one here either?

I know you did because three others saw it too.

But I dreamed up the second one?

Doctors can have hallucinations too.